Welcome, Guest Login Register
loading...
Net Promoter Community > European Conference Blog 2008 > 2008 > May > 01
 

Word of mouth is all about the money, the rest is just conversation (pun intended). That's the key takeout of this roundtable on Net Promoter and word of mouth; tell me how much a recommendation is worth, and then I'll think about doing something about it.

 

Part of the attraction of Net Promoter Score is its link to hard financials, but the NPS itself measures propensity to recommend (would recommend), not word of mouth (do recommend).

As it happens, recent European research has found that only 50% of promoters (would recommend) actually do recommend.

 

There are some really cool and effective tools for activating the 50% of ˜silent" promoters that the average business unit has (such as online communities), but before time and money is spent, it's important to know how much a recommendation is worth in financial terms (see The Ultimate Question by Fred Reichheld, Net Promoter Economics: The Impact of Word of Mouth white paper by Satmetrix, and How Valuable is Word of Mouth white paper published by Harvard Business Review for calculating Customer Referral Value).

 

Only then can a business case be put together for activating promoter advocacy.

... more >>
0 Comments Permalink

Question: Why does the insurance industry use so many acronyms?

 

 

Peter Harmer, CEO at Aon UK suggests: "Could it be that insurance professionals are inarticulate, lazy or have bad memories?"

 

As designed, Peter's self-posed question and response ellicited a nice ripple of laughter from the audience but if Peter is indicative of other insurance professionals then I wouldn't believe a word of it. Serious, yes, but with a dry sense of humour. Confident, yes, but with a healthy streak of humility. Focused on the customer? Absolutely!

Working in an industry like insurance which is largely seen, and I quote, "as a bastion of conservatism and tradition"; introducing an innovative concept like Net Promoter must take quite a bit of gumption. And although Aon's program is still in its early stages, it appears that Peter's team are off to a successful start.

Aon is one of the largest insurance (re-insurance) companies in the world with over 36,000 staff in 120 countries generating $8 billion in annual revenue. They, like other players in the industry, have seen the movement of focus from tangible to intangible assets such as brand, reputation and supply chain dynamics. Aon have embraced the changing environment and in 2007, they took the opportunity to review their position in the marketplace through a series of dialogues with their customers. They weren't asking "what do you think of Aon and how should we change?" but the more salient question of "what is happening for you?". By understanding their customers' positioning, focus, future goals etc, Aon could then look at how they could best respond to their customers' needs.

Their articulated focus is totally customer-centric: "It helps our clients - or it helps our people to help our clients."

So how has the introduction of NPS impacted their business? Fundamentally it has become the bedrock of their customer interaction and understanding. It underpins their other key customer interactions: customer advisory groups, customer interviews and debriefings and client service reviews.

 

And why did they choose NPS? Acronym aside, they chose the metric and the underlying discipline because it was simple and robust, and had global presence and recognition.

Their review process and introduction of Net Promoter led them first to re-segment their customer base, focusing on revenue and customer type, rather than the more traditional approach of product. Reviewing the Net Promoter Scores by segment gave them new learnings around the way in which they managed certain customer bands. They also reviewed scores by respondent role and by region and again applied learnings from the analysis to communications and management programs both regionally and by job role.

Aon certainly focus on taking action on detractors to mitigate the risk of attrition, but what impressed me most was the way in which they work with their promoters. Understanding the promoters within the Aon revenue engine is key. Strategically, they are able to use promoter data to help define strategies around upselling, cross-selling and developing direct referrals. Tactically, promoters have become important in helping at marketing events such as customer recruitment drives. Let's just say that the power of promoters in helping to "sell" to prospects cannot be underestimated! Fundamentally, promoters are assisting in a number of ways to drive that revenue engine.

 

Key in all of this is the ongoing focus on the customer. This has led Aon to a healthy NPS of +25% and they continue to learn and refine the program. Now that Peter is making insurance more interesting I, for one, am looking forward to the next chapter!

 

Click here to download the presentation.

... more >>
0 Comments Permalink

Allianz is one of the world's largest insurance and financial services company. Their Customer Focus program is dedicated to creating a superior customer experience that maximizes customer loyalty, resulting in increased referrals, retention and cross-selling, profitable growth, and increased value for shareholders. Andrew Clayton, VP and Operations Director for Allianz, discussed their program.

 

 

The company has implemented a wide variety of Customer Focus tools to help them deliver on their promise to customers. These tools are organized around a framework focused on Listening, Learning and Change. NPS is measured from both a Top Down and Bottom Up perspective. The Top Down measures are used for management KPIs, to measure overall success of the program and benchmark against competitors. The Bottom Up perspective helps to mobilize front-line staff to be more customer-focused.

 

Linking NPS to organic growth is a critical factor in keeping top management attention. Allianz has convinced themselves of the linkage by not only tracking their own numbers, but by also studying competitive performances as well. Tracking the value of a Promoter vs. the value of a Detractor is key to driving the program.

Allianz has a 91% participation rate in their NPS surveys. Furthermore, customers are willing to participate in follow up calls. The participation rate seems high but perhaps Allianz has found a way to keep it short and rewarding.

For Allianz, as with other NPS practitioners, it's not about the number, but about driving continuous business improvements. The NPS program at Allianz is not a new one -- Andrew frequently made references to "we did that a number of years ago". One gets the picture of a mature program with wide participation by various parts of the organization.

 

Key success factors:

  1. Have a well-defined scope
  2. Include experts from your operations team
  3. Set up a cross functional team
  4. Effective communication
  5. In-depth training
  6. Early identification and implementation of quick wins
  7. Recognize and reward success
  8. Embed NPS as part of a performance measurement system

 

 

Mobilizing a large organization is not easy. It appears that the next move for Allianz is to institutionalize NPS.

 

Click here download the presentation.

... more >>
2 Comments Permalink

Having completed the first day of the conference, it certainly feels that the subject of communities is a growing concept for developing deeper relationships with customers; and a customer community perspective is a perfect partner to a more established loyalty program. Communities and the relationship with NPS were also the focus of the start to Day 2, articulated by a great speaker and veteran of the community concept, Kip Knight from eBay.

 

Now, you would be forgiven for thinking that eBay see their community solely in terms of their online existence but it was great to hear from Kip that their concept of community goes much deeper and wider. Before looking at this further, let's just refresh on the background of the company.

  • Started in 1995, after a year of operations there were 41,000 users on eBay. Today there are over 248 million people active on eBay.
  • The vision of the company is to make it possible for practically anyone to sell practically anything in a worldwide marketplace.
  • At any one time, there will be 103 million items for sale on the site.
  • Over 1.3 million people make a large part or all of their living trading on eBay.

The eBay community itself is defined in terms of including everyone who has a relationship with the company. That really does include everyone --  from buyers and sellers to partners, vendors and associate organisations. This is known as eBay's eco-system and through the online platform and wider community, eBay have developed their strategic differentiation through a unique asset and developed a real tool to promote and develop loyalty and retention.

Perhaps the key driver of the success enjoyed by eBay is the early focus that was placed on a set of values underpinning the business. Those values were outlined as:

 

  • People are basically good.
  • Recognise and respect each person as unique individuals.
  • Everyone has something to contribute.
  • Treat others as you would want to be treated.
  • An honest, open environment will bring out the best in people.

 

As well as developing the online feedback tool, offline eBay has continued to develop the honest, open environment through live discussion events, "Bay In Person" visits, open dialogue and the member advisory group, Voices, who assist with ongoing developments. What eBay has found is that the more a member of the community is involved, the stronger their promoter status. And that involvement should not be limited to the online interaction.

 

So how does NPS fit into all of this? Well, first of all Fred Reichheld's Golden Rule is articulated as one of the core values. Secondly, eBay felt that the discipline would be core to developing best practice improvements, increasing competitive awareness, focusing on incremental investments and really enabling a deep-dive understanding of their members loyalty behaviour. The NPS discipline also appealed because it was based on a simple concept metric, it was easy to articulate and it provided a forward looking metric for the business.

 

Interestingly enough, as with some of my customers, it was not specifically the "Recommend" question that eBay used. After researching and analysing the data, it was found that "Intend to Buy" was a better-correlating metric for their business. They are now moving to "Recommend" as it certainly is relevant to their business and it does allow for more benchmarking comparisons across a wider range of organisations as so many comapnies are using it as a key metric today.

eBay have melded their community and NPS program into a coherent approach to loyalty. It didn't happen overnight and Kip and the team spent time in defining and planning the program (you only get the one opportunity to implement this!), building the foundation and they are now moving into further evaluation and expansion.

 

Kip's key learnings from the implementation are:

 

  • Know when to centralise and when to delegate
  • Never stop learning
  • Process is king
  • One size does not fit all

 

And yes, it's not simple in any organisation to implement a loyalty program -- it comes with its own set of unique challenges; but as Kip ably demonstrated -- it's worth it!

 

Click here to download the presentation.

... more >>
1 Comments Permalink

So, you have measured Net Promoter. It's taken time to launch globally, and now the results are out.  What are some of the first questions you get from the CEO and regional teams? Do any of these sound familiar... "Is this a good score", "what about the competitors" and "what are the results for the other regions"?

 

As a seasoned researcher, it certainly does to me! And judging from the questions from the delegates after the Competitor and Cultural Benchmarking Session it seems that these questions are common in boardrooms around the globe.

The session conducted by James Young, Business Consulting Director for Satmetrix EMEA cautioned that there were a number of issues involved with answering these questions.  Frustratingly, it seems that there aren't always easy answers!

 

Sitting in James' session reminds me that there are a lot of considerations when trying to benchmark NPS.  These include cultural bias experienced in use of scales, robustness of sample and the industry in which you operate.  James advises that caution needs to be exercised when sharing benchmarks with senior execs as a lot of times they want to build it into compensation schemes or targets without much thought for these considerations.

 

James shared some insight around research that Satmetrix recently conducted in the US.  It appears that NPS scores differ greatly by industry and (surprise, surprise) the Telco industry tends to score lower NPS (circa 2%) than the financial services industry (circa 20%).

 

Also, when it comes to cultural bias (again looking at Satmetrix B2B research) customers in Latin America tend to score higher on NPS (average 35%) while the folks in APAC tend to be more reserved with their ratings (average NPS -10%).  Getting hold of free country level NPS benchmarks is like gold dust so James shared some online resources that people might find useful.

 

 

 

When it comes to competitive benchmarking, James shared the basics of how this could be achieved.

 

  1. Ask competitor questions in your own survey. Upside this is probably the cheapest way to get benchmarks, downside there is likely to be a positive bias as these are your own customers (so no true market position)
  2. Primary data.  Often research companies publish their own benchmarks based on the surveys they conduct.  This is probably more expensive than option 1.
  3. Custom or syndicated panel of non customers.  Upside: this probably the best indication of market position. Downside: probably more expensive than the other options

 

An important message communicated from the session was that while benchmarking plays an important part of an NPS programme, it really depends on where you are in the journey.  If your business is just starting with NPS, it may be more productive to concentrate on moving the scores for your own organization first, then after your programme has matured for a year or two, begin to incorporate competitor and/or cultural benchmarks. This gives the business time to absorb and action customer feedback and for the customer NPS programme to be embedded in the DNA of an organization.

... more >>
0 Comments Permalink

One of the strengths of Net Promoter is its simplicity. It's incredibly easy to ask the ultimate question and to use the answers as a helpful business benchmark. But this simplicity is also its weakness if organisations don't use it as originally designed by Fred Reichheld and Satmetrix; to be an enabler for business improvement. A lot of people I spoke to yesterday are using NPS to identify detractors and to remove the sources of detraction. This makes a lot of sense because research shows that detractors can be more influential than promoters. Indeed work at the London School of Economics shows that one negative recommendation takes up to four positive ones to counter it

 

This approach has been endorsed by the brilliant case study from Virgin Media - find out what you do badly and improve it. As a former NTL (acquired by Virgin Media) customer I can definitely see the fruits of this exercise! However, very few people I spoke to are activating their promoters. LEGO showed the powerful returns that this can deliver. You see there is a marked difference between the scoring a 9 or 10 and actually recommending - and perhaps more importantly, recommending on a regular and systematic basis.

 

The secret to converting a promoter into an advocate is to Listen using NPS, Involve by treating them as advisers (through more systematic research) and Empower by actually allowing them to shape your future direction - just as Lego has done with its power users. And don't be put off from doing so just because you don't work for an iconic brand like Lego. Promoters already love you - because you exceeded their expectations. Turn that love into an active daily passion by making them part of your business.

... more >>
0 Comments Permalink