Welcome, Guest Login Register
loading...
Net Promoter Community > European Conference Blog 2008 > Authors > KipKnight
 

I really enjoyed hearing Jana Eggers, the CEO for Spreadshirt, share her thoughts and "lessons learned" about NPS. A lot of what she shared can be applied directly to other businesses considering NPS as a key part of how they listen and respond to their customers.

 

 

One of the first things I learned during Jana's presentation was about Spreadshirt, the company she's managing as CEO. Spreadshirt is an internet enabled company that's a worldwide leader for creative, personalized apparel. It was started by a grad student in 2002 in Germany and has since grown to over 250 employees.

 

 

Spreadshirt has a direct-to-consumer business (with 700,000 customers) as well as 500,000 "shop partners" who design and sell customized T-shirts online via using Spreadshirt's platform and production capabilities. They've also got some large corporate clients such as CNN (where you can order a current headline on a T-shirt or jersey...how cool is that?).

 

 

Spreadshirt's key users are consumers who simply want to express themselves in a wide variety of creative ways through words and graphs on various types of apparel. Unlike a lot of their competitors, there's no minimum order quantity and they're proud of the "value for money" they offer their customers.  Another key selling feature is most Spreadshirt orders are shipped within 48 hours of being submitted.

 

Before coming to Spreadshirt as their CEO, Jana spent some time with Intuit where she became a big fan of NPS. Intuit was one of the "early adopters" of Net Promoter and continues to be one of its biggest advocates. Jana successfully used verbatims from NPS surveys when she was in charge of QuickBase at Intuit to help identify and implement quick wins in the business.

 

 

When she arrived at Spreadshirt last year, the good news was the company was already a consumer-centric culture. The challenge was it didn't have an overall guiding customer metric for the customer voice to be heard. They needed a way to talk and think about their customers and needed to break away from the tendency to say "if customer service hasn't heard about an issue, it's not an issue we care about".

 

Jana has used NPS to make sure Spreadshirt has an aligned way of listening and responding to their customers from all over the world. She implemented NPS across all the business units in 2007 and made sure NPS data was an integral part of everyone's SMART goals (i.e. specific, measurable, actionable, realistic and time bound).

 

 

Jana initially rolled out the NPS program in her core markets in three languages (German, English, French) with an email survey sent out to customers once a month. They have now included all their markets and do automatic email mailing after an order is placed or set-up.

 

 

They've also learned the wording of the invitation e-mail (such as subject heading) has a significant impact on the response rate to their NPS surveys. Based on this insight, they are continually experimenting with different e-mail subject headings and wording to improve their response rates.

 

Spreadshirt has developed some key early insights due to NPS which has led to a better understanding of their customers. For example, they've confirmed that Promoter re-order rates are 60% higher than that of Detractors. Additionally, customers who don't respond to their NPS surveys tend to have a similar NPS score as Detractors.

 

 

Having worked with NPS before at Intuit, Jana also appreciates that while the overall concept of NPS is simple to explain, it can be quite challenging to implement effectively across different markets. Another key lesson in implementing NPS she's applied at Spreadshirt is the critical need to balance short term vs. longer term issues.

 

 

For example, if you focus solely on long term issues, there's a danger of the organization giving up when they don't see progress in a relatively short time frame. If you focus solely on short term issues, you ignore the bigger strategic issues that are going to cause major problems in the future. The art and science of NPS is how to find the right mix of addressing both types of issues at the right time with the right team and resources.

 

 

Now that NPS data is coming in continuously from the various Spreadshirt markets, they've created an NPS dashboard that has all country data available for easy access. There's a "general assembly" for all employees held every month to review current business performance with only two PowerPoint slides (which should be a "gold standard" for any management meeting!). The first slide shows the number of shirts shipped the previous month and the second slide is an update on NPS data.

 

 

That's it...two slides....talk about focus!  And it highlights the importance that NPS has at Spreadshirt to all employees on a regular basis.

 

 

A major point Jana made throughout her presentation is teaching all employees, especially new leaders, about the importance of NPS. Everyone in the organization should be familiar with your NPS scores and key drivers behind the scores.

 

 

It's important everyone in the organization understands you will get different NPS results due to cultural differences. For example, the US and UK scores tend to be higher than those from France and Germany.  Additionally, smaller countries tend to have greater flux in their scores than larger countries.

 

That means there's a real risk of managers turning NPS scores to a contest to see "who's #1 and who's not". This belief would be a major detriment in making NPS a core part of how they manage the Spreadsheet business.  To make sure this doesn't happen, Jana emphasizes that while everyone naturally likes to be #1, the important thing to remember is it's all about improvement in their NPS scores, not the absolute number.

 

 

So what's next for Spreadshirt and NPS? Jana outlined three key areas, including:

 

 

  • Understanding success factors that drive strong NPS scores
  • Continue to study country specifics (and what's needed to improve)
  • Benchmarking against other companies

 

 

That's it for this blog...now I'm going to think of a snappy NPS quote that I can put on a shirt and order on the Spreadshirt website!

 

Click here to download the presentation.

... more >>
0 Comments Permalink

Glenn Rogers, Director, Customer Experience, at Logitech presented a compelling business case based on his experience at Logitech on how NPS data can be used to prioritize and guide new product development as well as help transform a product focused culture into a consumer oriented one.

 

 

As background, Logitech is one of the leading providers of computer accessories (such as keyboards, mice, webcams, etc) in addition to a growing array of other popular consumer electronic products (such as Harmony, a no-brainer remote control that works with a wide variety of DVD players, TV's, etc).

 

I was surprised to learn just how complicated Logitech's business is, with 6 business units and over 100 new product launches every year. With such as large number of new product launches, quality isn't always consistent and there's the risk of alienating early adopters of a new product when quality isn't where it should be.

 

 

An additional challenge Logitech faces on a going basis (a challenge other consumer electronic companies face as well) is the relatively short "shelf life" of the product lines; the average Logitech product life cycle is only about 18 months! This requires constant innovation, which they've been quite successful in achieving over the past 25 years with an impressive 25% CAGR revenue growth.

 

As with many engineering driven companies, there is a strong focus on developing the next great product rather than starting with understanding what consumers really want (which is probably why none of us non-engineer types can ever figure out how to program our VCR's). Engineers intuitively want to know how to identify and fix "the bad stuff" (which is what Detractors are great at pointing out). Getting engineers to understand and appreciate what Promoters love about a product is a much harder concept to get across.

 

 

As a result of this challenge, Logitech has wisely chosen to go through a culture change while the business is good which will be heavily dependent on NPS as a "true North" guide to focusing on both Promoters and Detractors (and understanding what they both need).

 

 

Concurrent with this culture change initiative, Logitech re-organized the business in April 2007 with an EVP of Product as well as a CMO/SVP of Customer Experience (which includes marketing, customer support, customer experience and quality). The driving force behind these changes was a belief in "The Boomerang Principle"; i.e. the primary role of the business should be to focus on persuading current customers to return (i.e. creating promoters). This is a key principle many different types of businesses have confirmed is true; for example, 80% of Starbucks revenue comes from customers that come 18 times or more a month.

 

 

The re-org included the creation of a Customer Experience vision for Logitech, which is "a collective attitude that delivers on our Brand Promise by creating customer loyalty that leads to enthusiastic lifetime promoters who love and share Logitech experiences."

 

This long-term vision highlighted the need for two key priorities for the newly created Customer Experience team Glenn is creating:

 

  • Incorporating the "voice of the customer" into new product development
  • Integration of the customer experience into new product development process

 

 

Given these priorities, Glenn has been able to generate NPS scores for all of their product lines (which is very impressive given the large number of products) and is using this data to help improve product quality and processes. NPS is the key metric used to determine if Logitech is improving over time (and is a key input to the "Voice of the Customer" dashboard, which also includes returns to retail, customer support data and internet forum highlights).

 

 

Logitech's NPS journey started 18 months ago with few thousand responses using 5 point scale. This shifted in Q3 to an 11 point scale as well as the validation of NPS scores by product category and by product.

 

 

NPS data is collected via email and they are now generating 40,000 responses per quarter. Consumers are encouraged to go to www.logitech.com/ithink two weeks after a product is purchased. The NPS data is summarized on dashboards which are available to the business units and updated on a continuous basis.

 

 

Categorized verbatims were collected centrally last year (which took 5 full time people) but Glenn decided to get rid of this given the complexity of understanding verbatims from so many different product lines. The responsibility of analyzing verbatims is now with the respective business units who are expected to do regular "deep dives" on what's driving promoter and detractors. Glenn knows they still have lots of verbatims they're not doing enough with but is working on ways to gain additional insights from it in the future.

 

 

Understanding the economic value of NPS is also underway. Glenn is looking into ways to balance the short-term with long-term at Logitech. He's already determined the worst case with a Detractor is -$40 (product return plus negative WOM) using 20 year NPV plus negative WOM. He's still working on learning more about the upside potential that a Promoter has for the business.

 

 

He's also determined Promoters are almost twice as valuable as Passives in terms of long-term value and plans to use this knowledge to evaluate if additional investment in product is going to pay out (which would be a first for Logitech and a huge benefit to the consumer).

 

 

In 2009, Logitech will be expanding NPS to other regions and working to increase NPS response rates from non-software products (such as gaming, audio, keyboards), closing the loop via callback from customer service team and conducting quarterly "Voice of the Customer" workshops with each business unit to review the data and get the resources allocated accordingly.

 

 

In summary, Glenn outlined some key lessons Logitech has learned so far on its NPS journey:

 

  • You need a catalyst to get going (in this case, they decided to make this culture transformation while the business was still strong)
  • Top down support for NPS implementation  is absolutely critical
  • It's a long term journey (i.e. minimum 5 year game plan)
  • NPS is a philosophy that involves significant culture change
  • You need a small group to "own" NPS
  • Data collection is much more complex than anticipated
  • Your customers will thank you for doing NPS since it will improve their experience with products they buy and use on a daily basis

 

 

I've heard a number of other companies that have implemented NPS echo these same valuable lessons.  So for those of you considering NPS for your business, consider these principles to be key to your planning and strategy assumptions (or ignore them at your own peril).

 

Click here to download the presentation.

... more >>
12 Comments Permalink