Skip navigation
1

You never get a second chance to make a first impression. If you are in the hospitality business, you might think that the first impression is at reception. Or perhaps you consider the visual impact of the hotel entrance as a starting point.


But in many instances, and to your eternal shame, it’s the shuttle bus.


For airport hotels, the shuttle bus is the transition from the tender mercies of the airport/carrier system into the care of the hotel. The airport doesn’t run the shuttle bus, the hotel does. And yet, the experience is so incredibly varied for such a simple idea. You just need to get me the last mile (or perhaps a couple) in safety, comfort and yes, a reasonable timeframe. Doesn’t seem too much to ask, does it?


Airport hotel customers are professionals. Think George Clooney in Up In the Air. They have high airline status so they can check in quickly. They fold their clothes with military precision so they can pack for a week’s travel and 3 climates in a rolling-cabin-case, all to save a few minutes in baggage claim (or a few hours depending on your luck). They are Hertz #1 club members. In short, they have business travel down to a fine art, all with the goal of minimizing down time. They don’t plan on spending more time getting from the terminal to the hotel than it took to get from New York to Atlanta.


Enter the hotel shuttle bus…but I’m getting ahead of myself. First, we need to think about airport hotels.


The whole point of the airport hotel is to provide quick and easy access to and from the airport. We’re not staying there for the luxury or breakfast-buffet options. If marketed as an “Airport Hotel” we may reasonably expect it to have fairly close proximity to the airport. Look – I can see it from the airport exit! Even better, from the runway as we taxi! It’s THAT close, I can almost touch it!


However, two universal rules always seem to apply to airport hotels.

 

  1. However physically close, there must be no practical way of walking to the hotel. And if this rule is shamefully broken, there must be no smooth path to enable rolling luggage. Even Sherpa Tensing would give up on traversing the freeway/parking lots/swamp/minefield (mountain?!) that lies between the airport and the airport hotels.
  2. To get there, you must take the shuttle bus. The local cab drivers, even if willing to break the rules and take such a short fare – “I waited 20 minutes to get to the front of the taxi rank – for THIS?” – must be coerced into refusing the journey. Some system of collusive rules must conspire to prevent any other option.

 

So that leaves us with the bus. Shuttle bus schedules operate in a system that has been modelled by operational research experts. The colder the outside temperature, the less frequent the cycle. Apparently, buses must slow down with cold weather. This ensures you only wait a long time when it’s too cold to wait a short time.


The routes are cleverly designed so that the bus will make multiple hotel stops and – here’s the sophisticated bit – will always reach your hotel last. This is designed to present you with all the alternative forms of accommodation that you declined because it was too expensive for your travel policy. I can now perform flash-card recognition of every entrance to Chicago O’Hare hotels in less than 15 seconds.

The bus must be driven either very slowly, à la Mr Magoo, or in the style of Mario Andretti, presumably to make up the time you spent waiting for the bus in the first place. There will be no seatbelts.


You probably have your own favorites. Mine is the “Hotel Hopper” system. Devised for London Heathrow Airport hotels, the transportation officer responsible has obviously never set foot in an airport, on a plane – let alone a bus! Is this the same Brit who, 100 years earlier, divided India from Pakistan without having been to India?


In a transport system that can whisk you to central London in 15 minutes on the Express train, it can take 45 minutes to reach a hotel visible from the runway. And you pay for the privilege because the buses seem to be run by the same people who offer double-decker bus tours of the city. Apparently, visiting 10 other hotels en route is worth a few quid.


Why should you care? If you run one of these hotels, your customer arrives cranky and frustrated. That’s the first customer experience they have of your brand. Aren’t you missing an opportunity?

2

There is a danger in trying to be humorous, especially when you have personal experience of how hard it is to deliver a great presentation. Nevertheless, when I discovered that Alan Ruben had penned a classic on scientific seminar presentations, I couldn’t resist attempting a translation for those of us who labor to create material for the Net Promoter conferences. I hope you enjoy this in the spirit in which it is intended, fellow presenters…

 

When the speaker says: I’m pleased to give you this talk this morning because I always enjoy sharing our Net Promoter success with peers from across the world.

The speaker really means: Miami in February beats NYC any day!


When the speaker says: This has been an incredibly exciting year for us.

The speaker really means: My cardiologist is insisting this is my last presentation on Net Promoter, and my spouse organized an intervention.


When the speaker says: To be fair, there has been some debate in the management team about this point.

The speaker really means: We have an army of mortal enemies amongst our sales force, and they are so very wrong.


When the speaker says: This led us to ask a different question.

The speaker really means: Our budgets ran out.


When the speaker says: I’ll just talk briefly about this.

The speaker really means: I will talk about this for at least an hour. I am unaware that time is finite. I am your overlord.


When the speaker says: This result was completely unexpected.

The speaker really means: This result pissed us off. Two of our program team cried.


When the speaker says: At this point, I went back to the best-in-class practices.

The speaker means: At this point, I instructed my program manager to go back and actually read the books.

…Although, actually, the speaker really means: At this point, I instructed my program manager to go back and read the books, but he just posted some queries on netpromoter.com, so I had to read “Answering the Ultimate Question” for the first time.


When the speaker says: I don't need audio visual tools or an internet connection; I'm just going to give a "chalk talk."

The speaker really means: Me caveman! When me done talking, me hunt mammoth!


When the speaker says: This was just a first wave of NPS data

The speaker really means: I don't believe these results. I didn't even intend to show them to you, but this slide was prepared by a soon-to-be-ex team member who ignored my explicit instructions to leave this out.


When the speaker says: If we're right, this could be a significant business insight.

The speaker really means: We're not right.


When the speaker says: This is a social media “skunk works” program.

The speaker really means: This is what I wish we were working on full-time, but no one wants to fund it. I can’t even maintain a Facebook page for pete’s sake!

…Or: I want to give you the impression that we're also doing incredibly innovative work, though I'm not going to show it to you.


When the speaker says: I've even put together a video for you to watch.

The speaker really means: I'm about to click a button in PowerPoint, at which time nothing will happen. A room full of people who think they're smart -- including you -- will try to help, but no one will succeed. I will assure you that the video was interesting and important and move on to the next slide.


When the speaker says: I'd like to thank a number of people.

The speaker really means: I will now take my time naming team members you've never heard of while you stare at their group photo and decide who is the hottest.


When the speaker says: I'll gladly take any questions you may have.

The speaker really means: Please, please don't ask anything difficult. I'm looking at you, 90-year-old, Methuselah, Nobel laureate-author of 10 books on customer experience in the front row. If you raise your hand, I'll pretend I don't see you and call on the timid-looking fresh out of college MBA tweeting at the back.